Ranking the Most Popular Crappie Lakes in Minnesota: Updated 2025

What is the Best Crappie Lake in Minnesota?

With over 10,000 lakes in Minnesota, answering this question is not straight forward. There are countless solid Crappie lakes across the state and any of them could yield the limit. Surfing the web searching for the answer, I found a ton of different opinions. But the problem with opinions is that they are extremely biased, so how the heck was I supposed to know what the true answer was?

As a design engineer of jet engines, I enjoy data. Especially when making important decisions like, where should I fish? So instead of searching for an expert opinion, I decided to analyze the 10 largest lakes using Minnesota’s DNR latest lake survey data from the Lake Finder tool. After spending a few hours analyzing the data, I came up with a method to rank the best Crappie lake in Minnesota.

Of the 10 largest lakes in Minnesota, my methodology ranks Kabetogama Lake as the best for Crappie. Kabetogama Lake stood out as having the most abundant Crappie per Gill Net which is why I’m ranking it the # 1 Crappie Minnesota Lake for 2025.

If you are interested in my analysis of the best Crappie lakes from the thousands of lakes surveyed by the DNR, please sign up for my newsletter! I’m working on a report and will be sending it exclusively to my email list.

Subscribe and Get Exclusive Crappie Information

What is a Gill Net Survey?

Minnesota’s DNR takes fish surveys across the thousands of lakes they manage. They use Gill Nets, which are approximately 250 feet long, to capture fish. The fish are counted, weighed, measured and then thrown back. The DNR takes multiple samples across each lake which provides them data about whether the lakes are weak, healthy, or thriving fisheries. This data can also be used by anglers to determine which lake might be the perfect spot to catch the next state record!

My Methodology of Ranking the Top Crappie Lake in Minnesota

As previously stated, I analyzed Gill Net data from the top 10 largest lakes in Minnesota. Since Crappie can be found in schools, depending on where the Gill Nets are thrown they could either over or under sample Crappie. For this reason, I charted Crappie catch rate (CPUE – Crappie per Gill Net) every year. I then averaged the catch rate to see which stood out as the highest. When doing this, Kabetogama Lake stood out as the best Crappie lake

Now this only tells half the story. Some anglers (like me) not only want to know how many fish there are in a lake, but how big they are. I developed a BIG Crappie Index. In this index, I calculate the CPUE rate for catching big Crappie over 10 inches. The higher the number, the more slabs this lake produces. Consequently, while Kabetogama Lake has the highest Crappie catch rate, it also has the lowest BIG Crappie Index. So you will need to review the lakes yourself and determine which is the best for your trip.

For a more thorough analysis of the best Crappie lakes across Minnesota – sign up for my newsletter. I will be releasing a report shortly of my analysis of over a thousand bodies of water!

Subscribe and Get Exclusive Crappie Information

2025 Largest Minnesota Lakes Ranked for Crappie

Using this methodology, I ranked the largest Minnesota lakes in terms of Crappie production. The lakes are ranked as seen in the table below. Only Lake Pepin had White Crappie sampled by the DNR and in much smaller numbers. The average CPUE only reflects Black Crappie, but the sum of the CPUE includes White Crappie.

Note: I always check MN State fishing regulations for Crappie restrictions before my fishing trips and I recommend this for you too. I have not documented the fishing regulations in this blog.

1. Kabetogama Lake

• Size: 24,034 acres
• Max Depth: 80 feet
• Why It’s the Best: Kabetogama leads the list with an impressive 8.6 crappie per gill net (CPUE) and the highest overall catch numbers. While the lake has fewer big crappies, the sheer quantity makes it an excellent spot for steady action.
• Fishing Tip: Check out the Pines of Kabetogama. They have great fishing tips and can help you plan your next fishing adventure!

 

2. Rainy Lake

• Size: 210,200 acres
• Max Depth: 161 feet
• Why It’s a Favorite: With a CPUE of 6.2 and a decent number of big crappie (0.2 per net), Rainy Lake offers both numbers and quality fish.
• Fishing Tip: Check out this fishing guide of Rainy Lake by Northland Fishing Tackle. It provides some good details and advice for targeting all sorts of species including Crappie.

The chart below documents the Crappie catch rate per year (CPUE) and the Big Index (aka slab index). The chart shows a couple extraordinary years. This suggests that there are pockets of great Crappie fishing on Rainy lake, but also that the Crappie may not be easy to find. If the Gill Nets were cast in areas where the Crappie were not schooling this would be the reason for low CPUE. If the Gill Nets were cast in Crappie rich areas, this would be the reason for high CPUE. Since there is not a consistent CPUE, I highly recommend that you research the best areas on Rainy Lake for Crappie fishing before making your visit.

 

3. Upper Red Lake

• Size: 119,295 acres
• Max Depth: 15 feet
• Why It’s a Top Choice: While better known for walleye, Red Lake offers 4.7 crappie per net with a good number of big crappies (5.0 per net), making it great for trophy seekers.
• Fishing Tips: Reach out to Bear Paw Guides to book a guided fishing trip on Red.

4. Lake Pepin

• Size: 25,216 acres
• Max Depth: 60 feet
• Why It Stands Out: Lake Pepin has a 4.4 CPUE with some larger crappies mixed in (0.2 per net). Being part of the Mississippi River, crappies here grow fast and fat.

5. Mille Lacs Lake

• Size: 128,250 acres
• Max Depth: 42 feet
• Why It’s Ranked Here: While Mille Lacs doesn’t have a high catch rate (2.5 CPUE), its crappie population is steady, and the lake offers great multi-species action.

6. Lake Vermilion

• Size: 39,272 acres
• Max Depth: 76 feet
• Why It’s a Hidden Gem: While the overall crappie numbers are lower (1.2 CPUE), Vermilion boasts the highest big crappie count (0.4 per net), making it a great place for trophy seekers.
• Fishing Tip: Try fishing West Vermilion for Crappie. The western part of the lake is known for better Crappie success than the eastern part.

7. Leech Lake

• Size: 103,039 acres
• Max Depth: 150 feet
• Why It’s Worth a Visit: Leech Lake has a low CPUE (0.6) but still produces some big crappies (0.2 per net). If you’re patient, you can find quality fish.

8. Cass Lake

• Size: 15,958 acres
• Max Depth: 120 feet
• Why It Made the List: With a 0.5 CPUE and some larger crappies (0.1 per net), Cass Lake is a solid choice for anglers looking for variety.

9. Lake Winnibigoshish

• Size: 56,471 acres
• Max Depth: 70 feet
• Why It’s Low on the List: With a CPUE of just 0.2, the numbers aren’t great, but occasional big fish (0.7 per net) still make it a viable crappie lake.

10. Lake of the Woods

• Size: 725,583 acres
• Max Depth: 210 feet
• Why It Ranks Last: Despite its size, Lake of the Woods has a very low CPUE (0.2) and no big crappies recorded. It’s still a legendary fishery for other species.

Conclusion

If you’re looking for numbers, Kabetogama, Rainy, and Red Lake are the best bets. If you’re after giant crappies, Vermilion should be at the top of your list. Whether you’re fishing open water or through the ice, Minnesota has world-class crappie fishing for anglers of all skill levels.

What’s your favorite crappie lake in Minnesota? Drop a comment below!

References

Fisheries, M. a. (2024, January 26). Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. Retrieved from LakeFinder: https://www.dnr.state.mn.us/lakefind/index.html0